On November 20, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting en banc, held that Congress violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause when it passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 (the Act). As a result, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) are barred from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) against the State of Texas. Importantly, because Texas limited its challenge to certain portions of the Act, including the PWFA, the decision applies only to the PWFA and only to the State of Texas.[1] State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386 (5th Cir. Nov. 20, 2026) (en banc).

 How Did We Get Here?

Congress must have a quorum in order to do business. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the House of Representatives adopted a rule allowing members to record their presence by proxy for purposes of establishing a quorum. In other words, an absent member could authorize a member present in person to vote on their behalf. The House relied on this rule to pass the Act, counting hundreds of absent members as present. Of the 427 members who voted, only 201 were physically present. The Senate then passed the bill, and President Biden signed it into law.

Texas argued that the House’s presence by proxy rule violated the Quorum Clause, meaning the House did not validly pass the Act because a quorum was not present at the time of the vote. The Fifth Circuit examined the Constitution’s text, the framers’ original understanding, and historical practice. The Court agreed with Texas, held the Act was unconstitutionally adopted and affirmed the district court’s permanent injunction enjoining enforcement of the PWFA against Texas.

Eight judges dissented. Among other things, they questioned “why, if the entirety of the statute was unconstitutionally passed, this court’s judgment should be limited only to one small sliver of the multi-trillion dollar bill” and “how Texas may seek to enjoin enforcement of the PWFA despite accepting millions of dollars under the very same Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023.”

What Does This Mean For Employers?

Maybe nothing. But maybe something for employers who are currently facing EEOC charges or other PWFA litigation.

Because the decision applies only to the State of Texas and its state agencies, private employers should continue to comply with the PWFA and provide reasonable accommodations to employees and applicants with known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. Moreover, regardless of whether the PWFA is enforceable, employers have leave, accommodation and/or non-discrimination obligations related to pregnancy, childbirth, and related conditions under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. And many state and local governments have adopted pregnancy accommodation laws similar to the PWFA, which are not affected by this quorum issue. The Fifth Circuit’s decision will likely accelerate what is already expected to be a busy year for new state and local pregnancy accommodation laws.

Private employers have filed similar lawsuits challenging the PWFA in the Fifth Circuit, and those cases were stayed pending this decision. Unless the decision makes its way to the United States Supreme Court, we expect those stayed cases to be revisited and decided consistent with the Court’s holding.

Can employers in other parts of the country bring similar challenges to the PWFA? Yes. But it remains to be seen how other courts will rule. Regardless of whether employers choose to file an injunction action, they may want to add a defense in any litigation and in response to any EEOC charge alleging a violation of the PWFA.

To settle the issue and head off similar challenges, Congress may try to pass legislation reaffirming the Act with a physical quorum. That would shore up not only the PWFA but also the Act’s other provisions.

While all of this gets sorted out, employers are wise to consider refresher training for HR professionals and managers on PWFA trends and compliance. Employers should also watch for the EEOC’s proposed amended PWFA regulations, which are expected to be released soon.

Employers with questions about this decision or the PWFA should contact the authors or the Jackson Lewis attorneys with whom they regularly work. Follow us at Leave It To JL, for updates on this trending PWFA issue, the upcoming release of the PWFA proposed amended regulations and all other things leave and accommodation.


[1] Texas initially challenged the Act with respect to the PWFA as well as an appropriation for the Department of Homeland Security’s Alternatives to Detention Case Management Pilot Program. The district court determined Texas lacked standing to challenge the Pilot Program, and the parties did not raise that issue on appeal.

Print:
Email this postTweet this postLike this postShare this post on LinkedIn
Photo of Patricia Anderson Pryor Patricia Anderson Pryor

Patricia Anderson Pryor is the office managing principal of the Cincinnati and Dayton, Ohio offices, as well as the Louisville, Kentucky, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. Patty remains purposefully poised on the precipice of the changing legal landscape, advising clients on everything from…

Patricia Anderson Pryor is the office managing principal of the Cincinnati and Dayton, Ohio offices, as well as the Louisville, Kentucky, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. Patty remains purposefully poised on the precipice of the changing legal landscape, advising clients on everything from vaccine mandates to the Dobbs response, to ESG and the attacks on DEI, to the impact of Loper Bright. The combination of Patty’s ability and tenacity to understand and apply workplace law to nuanced legal questions and specific situations results in clients perpetually asking this initial question, “What does Patty think?”

Patty is the National Head of the firm’s Emerging and Cross-Disciplinary Issues. She has over 25 years of experience representing and defending employers in nearly every form of employment litigation, including class actions. She represents and advises employers in federal and state administrative proceedings, in all forms of dispute resolution, including mediation and arbitration, and in managing all aspects of the employment relationship. She has represented employers before the EEOC, the DOL, the DOJ, OSHA, the OFCCP, and the NLRB, in addition to various state agencies.

Focusing on the best possible outcome for the client Patty takes a 360-degree view, working with employers to avoid litigation by developing effective policies and practices, including harassment policies, FMLA practices, attendance programs, affirmative action programs and wellness plans. She conducts proactive wage and hour audits, harassment investigations and compensation/pay equity reviews.

Patty is a core team member of the firm’s Disability, Leave & Health Management practice group and a leader of the Religious Accommodation Team. She provides practical advice to help companies respond to remote work challenges, paid and unpaid leave situations and the most challenging accommodation requests, all of which have been exacerbated by the pandemic, hybrid work and changes in the law.

Photo of Joseph J. Lynett Joseph J. Lynett

Joseph Lynett is a Principal in the White Plains, New York, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. and  and co-leader of the firm’s Disability, Leave and Health Management (DLHM) practice group. His practice focuses on assisting clients in meeting the legal and practical challenges…

Joseph Lynett is a Principal in the White Plains, New York, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. and  and co-leader of the firm’s Disability, Leave and Health Management (DLHM) practice group. His practice focuses on assisting clients in meeting the legal and practical challenges posed by federal and state laws protecting injured and ill employees, as well as disabled students and members of the public. Joe provides imaginative and creative solutions to the complex array of workplace disability and health management issues faced by both large and small companies.

Learn more about Joe Lynett on the Jackson Lewis website.

Photo of Tania J. Mistretta Tania J. Mistretta

Tania J. Mistretta is a principal in the New York City, New York, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. She partners closely with national and local clients to advise on challenging workplace law issues, providing strategic advice on how to achieve business objectives while…

Tania J. Mistretta is a principal in the New York City, New York, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. She partners closely with national and local clients to advise on challenging workplace law issues, providing strategic advice on how to achieve business objectives while ensuring compliance with the law.

Photo of Tara K. Burke Tara K. Burke

Tara K. Burke is the knowledge management (“KM”) attorney for Jackson Lewis P.C.’s Disability, Leave & Health Management practice group, and is based in the Cincinnati, Ohio, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. She works with employers to build positive and inclusive workplaces and…

Tara K. Burke is the knowledge management (“KM”) attorney for Jackson Lewis P.C.’s Disability, Leave & Health Management practice group, and is based in the Cincinnati, Ohio, office of Jackson Lewis P.C. She works with employers to build positive and inclusive workplaces and reduce legal risk through policy development, training, and employment law counseling.

Tara provides practical and legal advice to clients on employment law issues including harassment and discrimination prevention, diversity and inclusion, hiring and interviewing, internal investigations, disability accommodation and leave management, reductions in force, individual separations and employee relations issues. Tara works with clients, including multi-state employers, to identify the trends in workplace law and stay in compliance with the rapidly changing state-by-state legal landscape. Tara helps clients of all sizes and in all industries, create, revise and implement workplace policies and procedures including employee handbooks. She also routinely conducts workplace training for leadership, human resources, managers and employees on numerous topics including strong management practices that reduce legal risk and build effective teams, preventing sexual harassment by supporting respectful and positive workplaces, achieving winning results through diversity and inclusion, conducting investigations, and employee accommodations and leaves of absence.

Tara has defended employers in employment-related litigation and administrative proceedings.

In addition to working with for-profit clients, Tara also works with non-profit clients, including small non-profits, to provide employment law expertise to non-profit organizations supporting our communities across the country.