The recent Tenth Circuit decision in Hwang v. Kansas State University upholding the employer’s inflexible leave policy causes one to ponder the logic of leave as an accommodation under the ADA in a broader sense. When contemplating such issue, the “oxymoronic anomaly” relating to this issue comes to the fore. Just what is this anomaly?
reasonable accommodation
Inflexible Leave Policy is Fair, Lawful and Protects Disabled Employees, Says Tenth Circuit
Reports of the demise of inflexible leave policies—leave policies that result in termination if the employee is unable to return to work after a fixed amount of leave – are premature.
The EEOC has sued numerous employers, alleging that their “inflexible leave policies” were unlawful because they did not take into account the possibility of…
No Good Deed Goes Unpunished in ADA Telecommuting Case
This, my fourth and last post about the Sixth Circuit’s decision in EEOC v. Ford Motor Company (6th Cir. April 22,2014), deals with the adage, variously attributed to Oscar Wilde, Clare Booth Luce and a host of others, that “no good deed goes unpunished.”
Recall the plaintiff in this case, Harris, a resale buyer, had…
Impact of Requested ADA Accommodation on Co-Workers a Factor in Undue Hardship Analysis
One more thing about EEOC v. Ford Motor Company (6th Cir. April 22, 2014). (See previous posts about that case here and here.) We have posted about the growing number of court decisions recognizing that the impact on co-workers of a plaintiff’s requested accommodation is a factor in the undue hardship analysis. See here…
Where’s Barnett? “Two-Step” Analysis Missing in ADA Telecommuting Accommodation Case
The Sixth Circuit’s decision in EEOC v. Ford Motor Company is so rich with disability management lessons that one post just does not do it justice. So here is my second post on that case. (The first is here.) There will be more to come.
As we have discussed, the Supreme Court of the…
An Inconvenient ADA Accommodation—Telecommuting
In its 2005 guidance on working at home, or telecommuting, as a reasonable accommodation, the EEOC said that “[m]any employers have discovered the benefits of allowing employees to work at home through telework…programs.” I suspect as many requests to work at home are met with quiet groans by employers as by the excitement of discovering…
When It Comes to ADA Accommodation, Beware the “Barnett Slide”
Dance professionals would never confuse the “one-step” with the “two-step” and neither should employers when it comes to evaluating the reasonableness of a requested accommodation. The two-step analysis comes from the Supreme Court’s 2002 decision in US Airways, Inc. v. Barnett. The one-step analysis, much less favorable to employers, continues to be advanced by the…
EEOC Letter Comments on Substance of ADA Forms
To add structure to the often amorphous process of obtaining and evaluating requests for accommodations, employers seeking compliance, efficiency and consistency have developed forms to assist their efforts. In an EEOC Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) “informal discussion letter” replete with cautions for those employers, the OLC said: “The wide range of disabilities,…
Neither Godot Nor EEOC ADA Leave Guidance Likely to Arrive in 2014
In June 2011, the EEOC held a public hearing on leave as a reasonable accommodation under the ADA and suggested it might issue guidance on the topic. We posted previously that waiting for that guidance is like waiting for Beckett’s Godot, where those waiting come to the realization at the end of each day that…
Posts of Future Openings Haunt Hospital in EEOC ADA Suit
The EEOC has sued a hospital that granted an employee two months of medical leave and extended it for an additional four months, but denied her further medical leave and terminated her because her continued absence would cause it an undue hardship. EEOC v. Children’s Hospital and Research Center, Case No.”CV 13-5715 (N.D. CA.…